Skip to content
Advertisement

Thousands of out-of-state patients are coming to Pennsylvania for abortions they can’t get at home

Pennsylvania abortion clinics are accommodating an influx of thousands of out-of-state patients

In the months since the Supreme Court overturned the constitutional right to abortion, Pennsylvania clinics have hired more doctors, extended their hours, and hustled to get time-sensitive care to an influx of out-of-state patients.

Right after the court’s ruling, providers anticipated a 25% increase in out-of-state patients — roughly 8,500 more people — as some of Pennsylvania’s closest neighbors became the first to restrict the procedure. Ohio, for instance, prohibited abortion after the sixth week of pregnancy, though a judge has temporarily blocked the law.

Twenty-six states have or are expected to restrict abortion access, according to the Guttmacher Institute, leaving some 40 million people living in states without an abortion provider.

That leaves Pennsylvania in a unique position: Despite limited resources, it is the closest abortion care option for growing numbers of people.

“We actually are a keystone state,” said Susan Frietsche, a lawyer and the Western Pennsylvania director for the Women’s Law Project, which advocates for women’s health issues, including abortion rights. “The degree to which Pennsylvania protects abortion rights here is important for the whole region.”

  • There are 17 abortion clinics in Pennsylvania, the vast majority of which are clustered in the southeastern part of the state.

  • For the more than 600,000 women of reproductive age in this region, which includes parts of Ohio and West Virginia, Pittsburgh’s two clinics were the closest option for abortion care even before the Supreme Court ruling.

  • Before the Supreme Court ruling, there were other abortion clinics in nearby states. But as more states ban abortion, Pennsylvania will get more patients.

  • Three nearby states — Kentucky, Indiana, and West Virginia — have instituted complete or near-total bans on abortion. Kentucky has no exception for rape or incest.

  • The future of abortion in two other states is unclear. Near-total bans in Michigan and Ohio have been blocked by state courts for now.

  • If these states restrict abortion access, Pittsburgh clinics will become the closest provider for more than three times as many women as before the Supreme Court ruling, in a region that includes the residents of Columbus and Cleveland.

  • The upcoming Pennsylvania governor’s race could determine the future of abortion rights. Democratic nominee Josh Shapiro has said he would maintain access. Republican nominee Doug Mastriano supports a six-week abortion ban.

OHIO9 providers at riskPENNSYLVANIAMICHIGAN19 providers at riskINDIANA7 providers closedKENTUCKY1 provider closedW.VIRGINIALast clinic suspended abortion servicesVIRGINIANEW YORKPittsburghClevelandColumbusPhiladelphiaHarrisburgYorkAllentown

Since well before the court ruling, Pennsylvania has limited access by requiring parental consent for minors, mandating a consultation followed by a 24-hour waiting period, and imposing regulations on abortion clinics that health experts say are not truly necessary.

“The infrastructure has already been eroded,” said Alexis McGill Johnson, CEO of Planned Parenthood Federation of America, at a roundtable in Philadelphia on Sept. 12. “I don’t know what the tipping point is.”

Advertisement

Limited access in high demand

In the 1970s, Pennsylvania had more than 100 abortion clinics, but today, there are only 17, most clustered in the Philadelphia area. There are none between Pittsburgh and Harrisburg.

And while Harrisburg-area patients can turn to clinics in Allentown, York, or Philadelphia, the Pittsburgh clinics have long been the closest option for a broad area that stretches beyond Western Pennsylvania into Central Pennsylvania, Ohio, and West Virginia.

Demand has increased since the Supreme Court’s decision, with people traveling from other states, even as far as Texas, for care.

“It is so painful to think we are an access state” because resources are also restricted here, said Sydney Etheredge, CEO of Planned Parenthood Western Pennsylvania, which operates in the Pittsburgh area. She said calls tripled almost immediately after the ruling, with people “trying to find out if they can get this care safely and legally in our state.”

  • Allegheny Reproductive Health Center, Pittsburgh's only other freestanding abortion clinic, has patients who drive in from all parts of Ohio. The center saw a 60% increase in out-of-state patients after the Supreme Court decision, said Sheila Ramgopal, the center’s medical director.

  • Allegheny Reproductive Health is also treating patients who travel by plane from states such as Texas, which has among the most restrictive abortion laws. The clinic expects to serve between 6,000 and 7,000 people this year, up from 3,500 last year.

  • In order to accommodate more out-of-state patients, Allegheny Reproductive Health routinely urges patients from Central Pennsylvania to head east toward Philadelphia.

  • The number of out-of-state patients has doubled at Planned Parenthood Keystone clinics in York, Harrisburg, and Allentown — the vast majority from Ohio and West Virginia, said the affiliate’s CEO, Melissa Reed.

  • As more states restrict access to abortion, patients must travel farther. Providers expect even more out-of-state patients in the months ahead.

OHIO9 providers expected to closePENNSYLVANIAMICHIGAN19 providers at riskINDIANA7 providers closedKENTUCKY1 provider closedW.VIRGINIALast clinic suspended abortion servicesVIRGINIANEW YORKPittsburghClevelandColumbusPhiladelphiaHarrisburgYorkAllentownCentral PA toward PhillyCentral PA toward PhillyOhio to East PAW. Virginia to East PATexas to AlleghenyOther states to AlleghenyOhio to AlleghenyOhio to AlleghenyOhio to Allegheny

Allegheny Reproductive Health has been planning for two years to meet the demand. It now has 10 abortion providers, up from two a couple years ago.

To make more space for them, the clinic moved administrative staff to the basement and scaled back non-abortion services that are available elsewhere, such as obstetrics.

The clinic can typically schedule patients for an abortion within one to two weeks, critical because Pennsylvania allows the procedure through the 23rd week of pregnancy.

Advertisement

Traveling across Pa. for abortion

From Pittsburgh, the next closest clinic in Pennsylvania is in Harrisburg.

Planned Parenthood’s Allentown clinic is seeing the biggest influx so far, despite being at least an hour farther than Harrisburg for people driving from Ohio.

Procedures at Planned Parenthood Keystone clinics are up 26%, in part because hours were expanded due to high demand.

The degree to which Pennsylvania protects abortion rights here is important for the whole region.
Susan Frietsche, Women’s Law Project

Currently, the Keystone clinics can provide abortion through the 13th week of pregnancy but will soon expand care through the 15th week, encompassing the vast majority of abortions sought in Pennsylvania. Though abortion is legal through the 23rd week of pregnancy in Pennsylvania, later procedures are riskier and may require a hospital visit.

Advertisement

Philadelphia anticipating a patient influx

Eastern Pennsylvania’s neighbors — New Jersey, New York, Delaware, and Maryland — all allow abortion. Some out-of-state patients, such as those coming to Philadelphia from Ohio or West Virginia, are driving past closer clinics that are booked up — or they’re flying to get here, said Dayle Steinberg, CEO of Planned Parenthood Southeastern Pennsylvania.

She expects to see more out-of-state patients because Philadelphia has a major airport or because they can stay with nearby friends or family.

Subscribe to The Philadelphia Inquirer

Our reporting is directly supported by reader subscriptions. If you want more journalism like this story, please subscribe today.

Still, Planned Parenthood’s Philadelphia-area clinics are busier than usual, likely because Western Pennsylvania clinic appointments are filling up more quickly.

The three regional Planned Parenthood executives recently joined the national organization’s CEO, McGill Johnson, at a roundtable discussion in Philadelphia where they warned of increasing strain on Pennsylvania’s resources — and the consequences for millions of people if abortion rights are restricted here.

“Pennsylvania is a critical state in the provision of abortion care in our nation,” Reed said.

About the analysis

The Inquirer’s analysis uses driving times to identify the closest abortion clinic for each Census tract and county in Pennsylvania and nearby states.

The Inquirer calculated the distance from the population center of each tract and county to each abortion clinic in the Abortion Facility Database from Advancing New Standards in Reproductive Health at the University of California San Francisco. The locations were pulled in July.

Driving time was calculated using Openrouteservice travel graphs built on a national extract of OpenStreetMap data from Geofabrik.

Estimates of the number of women of reproductive age come from the Census Bureau’s American Community Survey for the 2016 to 2020 period. Women of reproductive age are defined as those ages 15 to 44.

Staff Contributors

  • Reporting: Sarah Gantz
  • Design and development: Jasen Lo
  • Data: Jonathan Lai
  • Editing: Letitia Stein, Sam Morris, Dain Saint
  • Digital editing: Felicia Gans Sobey
  • Audience engagement: Erin Gavle, Erin Reynolds
Advertisement