Phillies prospect Andrew Painter tops out at 100 mph in Arizona start, his first since 2023 elbow surgery
Painter said the results "weren’t exactly what I wanted,” but the most important thing was how he felt. "The arm’s healthy and that was the biggest takeaway."
/cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/pmn/QYPVCZ5BXBB6NGQIJEECRMXG3E.jpg)
SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. — Top Phillies pitching prospect Andrew Painter took the mound in a game on Saturday for the first time since undergoing Tommy John elbow surgery in July 2023. Pitching for the Glendale Desert Dogs in the Arizona Fall League, Painter topped out at 100 mph in his two innings. He allowed two runs on three hits including a home run, with two strikeouts and one walk in 29 pitches.
“Obviously, the results weren’t exactly what I wanted,” said Painter, the Phillies’ first-round pick in 2021. “But the arm’s healthy and that was the biggest takeaway. Everything felt like it was coming out good. I felt like my old self, so that’s all I can really take away from that.”
» READ MORE: Re-ranking our top 10 Phillies prospects as their seasons end, and what’s next for each in 2025
Painter entered 2023 as MLB Pipeline’s best pitching prospect, with a shot at cracking the Phillies’ starting rotation to open the season. He made his spring training debut against the Twins on March 1, 2023, and soon after was shut down with a sprained ulnar collateral ligament. Four months later, the Phillies announced Painter would undergo Tommy John elbow surgery.
In recent weeks, Painter, 21, had been throwing live batting practice.
He needed only nine pitches to complete a perfect first inning, setting the Scottsdale Scorpions’ top three hitters down in order.
Among the hitters Painter faced was the New York Mets’ Jeff McNeil. He played in two Arizona Fall League games over the weekend, completing a rehab assignment in anticipation of rejoining his club in Los Angeles on Sunday for Game 1 of the National League Championship Series against the Dodgers. Painter got McNeil to fly out to left field before striking out top San Francisco Giants prospect Bryce Eldridge to complete a clean inning.
“It was cool,” Painter said. “I thought they had a really good lineup, but it’s the same approach as everyone else. I’ve still got to go out there and do my job and pitch to my strengths.”
Painter ran into trouble in the second inning. He left a hanging slider up in the zone, which Tigers first base prospect Josue Briceno launched for a 446-foot home run to lead off the inning. Painter walked the next batter, Mets outfielder Drew Gilbert, on four pitches, before giving up a single to Pirates outfield prospect Sammy Siani.
Painter induced a double play from Charlie Szykowny but was unable to keep the Scorpions from tacking on another run, as San Francisco’s Kervin Pichardo rocketed an RBI double into the power alley in left-center, scoring the inning’s second run.
» READ MORE: The 2024 stat to know for each of the Phillies' top 10 prospects
Painter featured his typical four-pitch mix on Saturday, which includes a fastball, slider, curveball, and changeup. He relied mostly on his heater; 18 of his 29 pitches were fastballs. Painter’s fastball generally sat between 97 and 99 mph, and he hit 100 mph three times in his first outing of the fall.
“I feel good,” he said. “[I’m] a little sore, but we’ll bounce back [Sunday]. The big thing is, I’m healthy. I got the first one under my belt, and just [need to] build off it.”
Painter is expected to pitch 20 total innings in the AFL. The Phillies planned for Painter to toss two on Saturday, with hopes of ramping him up in the coming weeks. The AFL’s season runs until Nov. 16 and features some of the top minor league prospects.
Painter told reporters postgame that he does not know when he will pitch next, but he’s excited to be back.
“Obviously, baseball has been my thing, and it’s something that I have loved,” Painter said. “So getting that taken away from me, I think it made me appreciate the game so much more. I just really look forward to any time I get to be on the field.”
If everything goes well, Painter should be in the mix for the Phillies sometime during the 2025 season. For now, he’s just embracing the opportunity he has been given.
It’s “a new chapter,” he said. “It’s a new elbow. I’m a new person now. The end goal is to pitch in the big leagues and pitch in the big leagues for a while. It’s a good balance of obviously knowing where your feet are at, [and] knowing that there’s light at the end of the tunnel.”