City Council may try to overhaul Philadelphia’s foster care system
Council will consider legislation requiring the city to take control of the foster system instead of contracting outside agencies, following the death of 10-year-old Malayshia Allford.

Philadelphia City Council will soon consider legislation that would force the city to overhaul its child welfare system and exercise more oversight of foster care placements.
City Councilmember Cindy Bass introduced a bill on Thursday that would require the Philadelphia Department of Human Services to move away from outsourcing child welfare case management to privately contracted agencies and for the city to control the foster system itself.
The development follows the death of 10-year-old Malayshia Allford, who was in foster care. Her foster mother, Carprice Williams, a former teacher in the Philadelphia School District who faced a previous allegation of abuse, was charged this month with Malayshia’s murder.
“We’ve been asking DHS to do this on their own for a very long time,” said Bass, a North Philadelphia Democrat who has for years been critical of DHS. “It’s quite apparent as of now that they haven’t done it, they don’t intend to do it, they won’t do it. And we’re going to have to make them do it.”
» READ MORE: At a memorial for Malayshia Allford, grief gives way to calls for justice
The new legislation raises the stakes ahead of a Council hearing scheduled for Friday morning, when members will question city officials about Philadelphia’s procedures and whether systemic failures played any role in Malayshia’s placement.
Williams had been previously accused of abuse and a state agency recommended that she never foster again. However, she successfully appealed that finding and her record was expunged.
» READ MORE: How the paths of 10-year-old Malayshia Allford and a Philadelphia teacher tragically collided
Friday’s hearing is being held by the Committee of the Whole, which means that all 17 Council members will have the opportunity to question city and school district officials. DHS is led by Commissioner Kimberly Ali, who has worked in the agency for more than 25 years.
Council’s probe is one of multiple investigations into the system following Malayshia’s death. Mayor Cherelle L. Parker established a special committee to examine what went wrong, and District Attorney Larry Krasner said his office would conduct an independent review.
A spokesperson for the Parker administration declined to comment.
Bass’ new legislation will be referred to a committee for its own hearing, and must first pass out of committee before it can be considered for a vote by the full Council.
The bill would require the Philadelphia Department of Human Services to develop a comprehensive plan to transition away from the city’s unique child welfare system, which relies on a patchwork of nonprofits to manage services for children and families.
Those nonprofits, called community umbrella agencies (CUAs), provide case management across 10 service areas. The system was created in 2013 as part of an overhaul of the child welfare system that was intended to localize services so that agencies are based in the neighborhoods they serve.
A 2025 Inquirer/Resolve Philly investigation found significant problems with the system, including overburdened caseworkers, high turnover, and little progress on the number of near-fatalities and deaths of children.
That reporting also found that CUAs have faced dozens of lawsuits alleging that children in foster care were abused, and that core oversight problems traced back to DHS.
DHS already handles investigations of alleged abuse by families and identifies cases when children should be removed from their homes. CUAs take over from there, handling case management for families and identifying foster homes for placement.
Malayshia was receiving case management services from Catholic Community Services, one of the city’s contracted providers.























