Skip to content
Advertisement

Which Philly mayoral candidate do you align with the most?

Take our test and find out

Philly’s 100th mayor is likely to be a Democrat. And when it comes to primaries, small differences of opinion on issues can make all the difference.

However, those differences are not always easy to parse, and the circumstances surrounding policy choices can change over time.

This is why we came up with the political thumbprint. It’s a way to represent stances on the current issues at a broader, more philosophical level. Individualist approaches tend to look more to private citizens and businesses to solve societal concerns, whereas collectivist policies view problems as structural and place more responsibility on the government.

Think of the political thumbprint as a visual vibe check.

Public safety
Education
Taxes
Housing
Services
Collectivist
Mixed
Individualist

Take our survey to find out what yours looks like – and how well you’d be represented by this year’s candidates for mayor when you vote on May 16th.

For each question below, select the option that best describes how you feel.

Your Thumbprint

Question 1 of 7

The Philadelphia police department has the largest budget of any city agency. How should the next mayor address funding the police?

  • Increase police spending and hire more cops to address the gun violence crisis.
  • More cops is not the answer. Make the city safer by transferring funds to social services and education.
  • The budget is fine but we need to reform the department and make it more effective.
  • I care about public safety but I'm not sure what's the best way forward.

Question 2 of 7

Stop-and-frisk is a controversial police tactic where officers search pedestrians they believe are carrying illegal weapons or contraband. Do you support stop-and-frisk?

  • Yes, get back to stop-and-frisk. It worked in the past.
  • No, stop-and-frisk leads to racial discrimination in Black and brown neighborhoods.
  • Cops should be able to use stop-and-frisk, but it should limited.
  • I don't know enough to say whether I support stop-and-frisk policy or not.

Question 3 of 7

The mayor appoints members of the Philadelphia school board and is involved in education funding decisions. How should the next mayor address public education?

  • Significantly increase funding for traditional public schools and not charters.
  • Families need more options. The next mayor should help to improve access to charter and private schools.
  • The top priority should be removing asbestos, lead and other environmental hazards from school buildings.
  • I’m more focused on where mayoral candidates stand on other issues than I am on education.
Advertisement

Question 4 of 7

Philadelphia has the nation’s highest wage tax rate but a relatively low property tax rate. What should the next mayor do about city taxes?

  • Cut the wage and business taxes, even if that means allowing property taxes to increase.
  • It’s important to keep property taxes low to fight gentrification, even if that means keeping the wage tax high.
  • Increase taxes or create new ones, such as a “wealth tax" on investment holdings.
  • Philly’s tax structure is a good fit for our city, and should be maintained.

Question 5 of 7

Some residents of gentrifying neighborhoods say their communities are being displaced. Developers, meanwhile, say the city makes it difficult and expensive to build. What should the next mayor do about real estate development and housing issues?

  • Give developers real estate tax breaks, and remove obstacles in the zoning code to encourage new housing projects.
  • Black and brown neighborhoods are being destroyed. We need to give neighborhood groups more power to stop development projects.
  • Build more housing and protect our neighborhoods. Let’s encourage new construction while also establishing strong affordable housing requirements.
  • Although considered messy, the current dynamic of push-and-pull between neighborhoods and developers is working just fine.
Advertisement

Question 6 of 7

How should the next mayor address conditions in Kensington, including the open-air drug trade?

  • Lead with law enforcement to clear out encampments and involuntarily commit people in active addiction or crisis.
  • Focus on harm reduction and establish a supervised-injection site to reduce overdose risk.
  • Continue to focus on containing the drug trade as much as possible and offering treatment to people who want it.
  • I'm not sure what the best way to improve conditions in Kensington is.

Question 7 of 7

How should the next mayor improve the delivery of basic city services, including trash collection, blight removal and rec center programming?

  • Privatize more city services, contract out more often, and sell off more city facilities to decentralize services.
  • Commit millions of dollars in taxpayer funding to hire more sanitation workers, expand blight removal efforts, and keep rec centers open on weekends.
  • Just spend city money better on more efficient and effective programs.
  • I don't know what the best way forward is, but they do need to be better.
Advertisement
  • Most Overlap

    2nd Most Overlap

    3rd Most Overlap

    4th Most Overlap

    Least Overlap

    This is your political thumbprint

  • Most Overlap

    2nd Most Overlap

    3rd Most Overlap

    4th Most Overlap

    Least Overlap

    Allan Domb

    You might not like their stance on…

    • Public safety: Domb has a tough-on-crime approach which includes support for “Terry stops.”
    • Schools: He wants to expand access to charter schools.
    • Taxes: Domb believes that cutting the city’s wage and business taxes will foster job creation and grow the local economy.
    • Housing and development: In a mayoral debate, Domb said that the key to affordable housing is to “utilize the properties that the city has control of.”
    • Public services: Domb says his administration will fill potholes within 72 hours of being reported and seal all abandoned structures in his first 100 days in office.

    Read their full profile for more.

  • Most Overlap

    2nd Most Overlap

    3rd Most Overlap

    4th Most Overlap

    Least Overlap

    Jeff Brown

    You might not like their stance on…

    • Public safety: Brown is against “the old style stop-and-frisk” but believes that stops with legal cause can keep Philadelphians safe.
    • Schools: He wants to increase career and technical education opportunities in Philadelphia's schools and address building conditions.
    • Taxes: Brown supports incremental cuts to wage and business taxes.
    • Housing and development: Brown wants to shut down the city’s land bank and sell off its assets to Black and brown developers.
    • Public services: Brown’s campaign slogan is “pick up the damn trash” and he’s gotten flack for his response to a question on the trash contract sending Philadelphia's waste to Chester.

    Read their full profile for more.

  • Most Overlap

    2nd Most Overlap

    3rd Most Overlap

    4th Most Overlap

    Least Overlap

    Helen Gym

    You might not like their stance on…

    • Public safety: Gym opposes stop-and-frisk. Her crime plan emphasizes “actual targeted interventions”, like having nurses, counselors, social workers, and teen wellness programs available in schools and areas most impacted by gun violence.
    • Schools: Gym is a longtime advocate of public schools and her campaign includes a $10 billion “Green New Deal”, a 10-year plan to modernize school buildings.
    • Taxes: She thinks the city’s tax structure needs an overhaul and as a City Council member opposed a business tax cut.
    • Housing and development: While on City Council, Gym spearheaded the creation of a program to reduce evictions.
    • Public services: Gym has advocated for a dramatic expansion of city services, including keeping libraries and recreation centers open on nights and weekends.

    Read their full profile for more.

  • Most Overlap

    2nd Most Overlap

    3rd Most Overlap

    4th Most Overlap

    Least Overlap

    Rebecca Rhynhart

    You might not like their stance on…

    • Public safety: Rhynhart wants to see police department reform, including rethinking the force’s patrol, data collection, and 911 response strategies. She also opposes stop-and-frisk.
    • Schools: Her campaign messaging focuses on making sure that every student has access to a high-quality neighborhood school.
    • Taxes: Rhynhart favors incremental reductions to wage and business taxes.
    • Housing and development: Her campaign promises to leverage the city’s 8,500 vacant lots to increase the affordable housing supply.
    • Public services: With a background in budgeting, Rhyhart says she would manage city overtime wages to fund improved city services.

    Read their full profile for more.

  • Most Overlap

    2nd Most Overlap

    3rd Most Overlap

    4th Most Overlap

    Least Overlap

    Cherelle Parker

    You might not like their stance on…

    • Public safety: Parker’s tough-on-crime approach includes hiring 300 more officers as part of a “community policing” plan and support for “Terry stops.”
    • Schools: She campaigned on a plan for year-round school. Parker also wants to change teacher recruitment efforts so that educators reflect the demographics of Philadelphia's student population.
    • Taxes: Parker wants to protect homeowners from rising property taxes, and supports incrementally lowering the wage tax.
    • Housing and development: One of her priorities is preserving established Black and brown neighborhoods. Parker has also vowed to create 30,000 units of affordable housing.
    • Public services: Parker has campaigned on expanding the PHL Taking Care of Business program, which is focused on cleaning and greening commercial corridors.

    Read their full profile for more.

Still can’t decide? Learn more about the candidates and other races, our comprehensive voter’s guide details every Democratic primary candidate. These candidates also went head-to-head in debates over these issues and more.

Did you find this story useful? Let us know your thoughts at interactives@inquirer.com.

Methodology

The Inquirer created a list of issues that matter to Philadelphians from interviews, reporting, and the results of the Every Voice, Every Vote poll. Our final set of issues were public safety and policing; schools and education; taxes; housing and development; and public services, including trash removal and recreation centers.

From there, we wrote up questions and answers to summarize different stances held across mayoral candidates on each issue. Each viewpoint is weighted across three axes – collectivist, mixed, and individualist – for each set of issues, and the result is displayed in a grid. In this way, it’s easy to see broad affinities between different people who take the quiz.

We calibrated the survey based on candidates' statements, campaign websites, and literature. Candidates’ stances did not always fall neatly into one category or another; in these cases, we weighted their answers across two axes. We included only candidates who have polled above 10%.

We calculate overlap between readers and candidates using a weighted average of visual and numerical comparisons. The final results list the candidates according to that weighting.

No result should be taken to be an official endorsement of a candidate nor be fully representative of their mayoral platform.

Advertisement

Staff Contributors

  • Design and development: Dain Saint, Sam Morris, Charmaine Runes
  • Reporting: Anna Orso, Sean Walsh