The 25 Under 25 ‘From Here’ List: Hannah Hidalgo, Kevin McGonigle, and the best athletes who no longer play in Philly

On Thursday, we released The Inquirer’s first list of the Philadelphia area’s 25 best athletes under 25 years old. But since that list was limited to those who currently play in Philly, we thought it was only fair to tip our cap to athletes who are originally from the region but no longer player here.

Here are 11 young college and professional athletes (listed alphabetically) who got their starts in Philly but currently star elsewhere …

New York Giants | Age: 22

At linebacker, Carter helped lead La Salle to the 2021 Philadelphia Catholic League championship before becoming a national name at Penn State. Now, the North Philadelphia native is looking to break out during his sophomore season with the Giants after being drafted No. 3 overall by the franchise in 2025. Last season, Carter finished with 25 solo tackles, four sacks, and two forced fumbles.

» READ MORE: From Jalen Carter to Jett Harrison, these athletes just missed the cut for our 25 under 25 list. Here’s why.

Louisville baseball | Age: 20

Davis was named the Atlantic Coast Conference Baseball Player of the Year after a successful sophomore season at Louisville. He led the nation with 34 home runs while driving in 98 runs. The West Chester native, who attended Malvern Prep, saw action for Team USA this summer in the inaugural World Collegiate Baseball Championship in Taiwan. The first baseman is the son of former major league catcher and Phillies color commentator Ben Davis. His younger sister, Riley Davis, is a standout lacrosse player at the Academy of Notre Dame de Namur and one of the 25 athletes to make our inaugural 25 under 25.

Tague Davis received significant attention from other programs after the Cardinals were bounced from the first round of the ACC postseason tournament, but he opted to stay in Louisville.

“Sometimes the grass ain’t always greener,” Davis told The Inquirer in July.

» READ MORE: Tague Davis is ‘reaping the rewards’ of his baseball journey at Louisville — and now with Team USA

Arkansas track and field | Age: 18

Dumas, a recent graduate of Eastern Regional, is heading to Arkansas for her freshman year. At Eastern, Dumas broke more than 20 program records and became the first girl to place first in three events at the NJSIAA Meet of Champions — the 400 meters, 400-meter hurdles, and 800 meters. Dumas became one of just 20 female high school track and field athletes to sign with Nike Elite — a coveted name, image, and likeness program.

“At the end of the day I’m not afraid to lose,” Dumas told The Inquirer in July.

» READ MORE: South Jersey track star Natalie Dumas proves it’s never too late to reach full stride

Detroit Pistons | Age: 22

Duren, a Sharon Hill native, played two high school basketball seasons at Roman Catholic before transferring to the prestigious Montverde Academy in Florida. After a single season at Memphis, Duren was selected 13th overall to the Detroit Pistons in the 2022 NBA draft. In the Motor City, Duren has made a name for himself as one of the most talented young bigs in the league. This past season, he was named to the All-NBA third team. He is currently a free agent but is expected to resign in Detroit.

Arizona Cardinals | Age: 24

Harrison Jr. was a star at St. Joseph’s Prep before playing college football at Ohio State. The wideout, who owns the Philadelphia Catholic League record book, was drafted No. 4 overall in the 2024 NFL draft by the Cardinals. Despite inconsistent play at quarterback, Harrison Jr. has logged 1,493 receiving yards and 12 touchdowns through his first 29 games. He is the son of NFL Hall of Fame wideout Marvin Harrison and the older brother of Jett Harrison, a standout receiver at Prep who is committed to Ohio State.

Team USA field hockey | Age: 22

Heck grew up in Shamong, Burlington County and played field hockey at Eastern Regional. There, she became a three-time state champion and an All-American. After high school, Heck took her talents to North Carolina. Through four years with the Tar Heels, she has collected two NCAA championships and four ACC titles. In 2023, she was named the National Field Hockey Coaches Association Division I National Player of the Year.

» READ MORE: Ryleigh Heck’s field hockey career won’t end at North Carolina. It’s just beginning with Team USA.

Notre Dame basketball | Age: 21

Before leading the Fighting Irish women’s basketball team, Hidalgo turned heads at Paul VI High School in Haddon Township. Hidalgo was named a McDonald’s All-American during her senior year at Paul VI before heading off to South Bend. Last season, the Merchantville native averaged 25.3 points. 6.9 rebounds, 5.2 assists, and a nation-best 5.6 steals. She also helped lead Notre Dame to an Elite Eight appearance.

“It gives us motivation,” Hidalgo told The Inquirer in March. “To be able to [reach the Elite Eight] with this team, when nobody thought we were going to get past the second round.”

» READ MORE: In a season of change for South Jersey’s Hannah Hidalgo, she led Notre Dame to new heights

Orange County SC | Age: 18

Johnson grew up in Voorhees and is a product of the Philadelphia Union Academy. The Union, however, were not able to retain the promising winger. Johnson, who was named to the 2025 MLS NEXT Pro All-Star game, signed with Orange County SC in January. Johnson has international playing experience, playing for the U.S. Youth National Team. He has seven goals in international play.

Track and field | Age: 22

Martin, who set records at Archbishop Wood, recently finished up his collegiate career at Virginia. In Charlottesville, Martin was a seven-time first-team All-American. During the 2025 NCAA Indoor Championships, Martin won a national title in the distance medley relay, running the last leg. He recently signed a professional contract with Brooks.

Detroit Tigers | Age: 22

McGonigle, a standout at Bonner-Prendergast, now stars at shortstop for the Detroit Tigers. The Media native has an on-base percentage of .384 and has scored 82 runs. This season, McGonigle made his All-Star debut at Citizens Bank Park and played in front of his “fan club” — a group of fans from Archbishop Prendergast High School that have traveled far and wide to watch him play.

» READ MORE: Kevin McGonigle had ‘unbelievable’ All-Star weekend, from sleeping in his childhood bed to meeting Chase Utley

Northwestern field hockey | Age: 22

Sessa, a Schwenksville native, won a national championship at North Carolina during her freshman season. After a single year with the Tar Heels, Sessa transferred to Northwestern. Her winning ways followed. Her sophomore and junior campaigns at Northwestern both ended with national titles. The two-time Big Ten Offensive Player of the Year is looking to go 4-for-4 by adding another championship to cap off her collegiate career.

She also has her eyes set out for the 2028 Olympics in Los Angeles.

“If I have a bad practice day, I let myself think forward a bit and just say, ‘You know what, this is good, I’m learning something new,’” Sessa told The Inquirer earlier this month. “This preparation will help me further in the future for the L.A. Games.