Skip to content
Link copied to clipboard

Counting down the 25 best Eagles to ever play in the Super Bowl: 20-16

by Ariel Simpson
Heather Khalifa / Staff Photographer

On Monday, we unveiled the first five names on our list of the the 25 best Eagles players to ever play in a Super Bowl based on their performance in the big game. That means only members of the 1980, 2004, 2017, and 2022 teams are eligible (sorry, Saquon Barkley). Now, the countdown continues with Nos. 20-16 ...

Yong Kim / Staff Photographer
Yong Kim / Staff Photographer

20. Fletcher Cox, defensive tackle

Before retirement, Fletcher Cox played in Philly for 12 seasons. The six-time Pro Bowler made two Super Bowl appearances, helping the team win their only title to date in 2017. Cox recorded one tackle and two quarterback hits in that game.

Jerry Lodriguss / Staff Photographer

19. Donovan McNabb, quarterback

If this was based on entire careers, Donovan McNabb, who led the team to five NFC championship games and a Super Bowl appearance (2004), would be much higher. But the six-time Pro Bowler threw three picks and struggled on the final drive.

AP

18. Harold Carmichael, wide receiver

Hall of Famer and four-time Pro Bowler Harold Carmichael played 13 seasons with the Eagles, earning four straight playoff appearances. He helped lead the team to its first Super Bowl in 1981, where he recorded five catches for 83 yards.

YONG KIM / Staff Photographer

17. Nelson Agholor, wide receiver

Before he became a meme, former first-round pick Nelson Agholor caught nine passes for 84 yards in the team's Super Bowl win over the Patriots. Agholor, who played five seasons with the Eagles, was Nick Foles' favorite target in that game.

MICHAEL BRYANT / Staff Photographer

16. Brian Westbrook, running back

Eagles Hall of Famer Brian Westbrook played eight seasons with the Birds. In their 24-21 loss to the Patriots in 2005, the two-time Pro Bowler recorded 44 rushing yards and 60 receiving yards, but was mostly held in check.

1/9