Skip to content
Link copied to clipboard

We’ve got the recipe for the famous Her Place chocolate chip cookie

The warm chocolate chip cookie that My Loup and Her Place Supper Club chef Amanda Shulman presents at the end of every meal is the stuff of legends—and now we have the recipe for it.

Her PlaceSupper Club's sourdough chocolate chip cookie
Her PlaceSupper Club's sourdough chocolate chip cookieRead moreTyger Williams

You’ll likely need to plan ahead to make these wonderfully thick and chewy chocolate chip cookies from Her Place and My Loup chef-owner Amanda Shulman, but trust us, they’re worth the effort. They’re one of our 8 show-stopping slam-dunk cookie recipes for this year—all contributed by local bakers, restaurant owners, and even one from a cheese shop.

Get one cup’s worth of sourdough starter discard in order first. You can make your own starter, of course, but several Philly bakeries, including Lost Bread and Mighty Bread, will give you a hunk of theirs for free so you can grow it. (Or take a shortcut and ask your homemade bread-baking neighbors.)

Citric acid helps bump up the sourdough flavor, but it’s optional. Shulman’s recipe calls for a ton of chopped chocolate (3½ cups’ worth), so buy a handful of bars. Chocolate chips are easy and they work, but we wish we had gone with chopped, because it distributes more evenly and has a more striking appearance.

Note that in the cookies in the lead image, we used chocolate chips rather than the chocolate bars that Shulman calls for in the recipe, which gives the cookies a slightly different appearance. Below, a photo of what the cookies look like with chopped chocolate instead:

Also, if you think you’ll make this recipe, brown the butter, let it cool, and set it aside in the fridge so you’ll be ready. Like we said, there’s planning involved — would you expect anything less from one of Food & Wine’s best new chefs? — but these might be the chocolate chips of the year. Plus, baking them is a surefire way of trying Shulman’s food without vying for a near-impossible reservation.

You can download the recipe here. And check out seven other stellar cookie recipes from Philly bakers in our annual cookie recipe round-up.

Buy it instead: Shulman plates up a smaller version of this cookie (served warm) at the end of every meal at Her Place at 1740 Sansom St.